Employee Screening | What To Look Out For

There are many things you need to look out for within your employee screening process.

On the surface, it may appear your new (or current) staff have the credentials, right to work, and experience they stated on their application.

But without the appropriate processes and tools, many aspects of your employee’s background may get overlooked. And the result? Financial, legal, and/or reputational damage.

In this article, we discuss what to look out for when conducting employee background checks.

Fake ID Documents and Right To Work Checks

ID documents are the most common form of fake documents provided by employees.

TrustID stated that the fake ID documents reported in 2021 included Biometric Residence Permit (BRP), passports, visas, ID cards and driving licenses. In addition, passports formed the largest group of fake documents.

If you fail to spot a fake ID document, then this will void a right to work check, which will lead to a maximum civil fine of £20,000 per individual, and/or a criminal sanction of an unlimited fine or imprisonment of five years.

To prevent the risk of accepting a fake ID, there are several things you can do:

Fraudulent Educational Certificates

Fake educational credentials are also common (and widely available to the public online). Many UK employers have reported candidate’s providing University degree certificates that, whilst seemingly authentic, were revealed to be fraudulent.

If you suspect your employee has provided a fake certificate, then you should contact the issuing body to determine its authenticity.

Conflicting Timelines

Conflicting (or clashing) timelines are a common cause for background checks failing. This may be caused by your employee providing inaccurate dates.

However, there are times when conflicting timelines can cause concern. For example, if your employee states they were in full-time education and full-time employment at the same time, then it is likely they have provided false or inaccurate information.

In instances where this occurs, you should ask your employee/candidate follow up questions and cross-check this information with the references they have provided.

Timeline Gaps

Common CV practice suggests that job seekers should indicate gaps in their employment or educational history and what they were up to during these times.

However, not all applicants provide this information, which may raise a red flag.

If your employee’s history has significant gaps (e.g. 3+ months), then you should ask them to clarify what they were up to during that time. However, as there is no legal underpinning to this practice, you can choose whether or not to ask any questions.

Criminal Record: Spent and Unspent Convictions

Whilst you may be unhappy to discover an applicant or existing employee has a criminal record, you should take action on a case-by-case basis.

Discovering that your applicant has criminal convictions

If an applicant has a criminal record and unspent convictions, then you must assess the potential impact this could have on your organisation.

Your decision to hire should be based around the role itself, and whether it really matters if they have a criminal record. Of course, this depends on the type of unspent convictions revealed.

This really matters if the role is an excepted role (those working with children and vulnerable adults). If you feel the unspent conviction/s revealed could pose a danger, then you can refuse to employ the applicant.

However, this changes if a criminal record check reveals a spent conviction/s. You can ask the applicant what the spent conviction was for, but they are legally allowed to withhold that information. Furthermore, you are not allowed to deny that person employment.

Discovering that your existing employee has a criminal conviction

If you discover an existing employee has unspent an criminal conviction/s, you should treat this case-by-case. Depending on the type of unspent conviction, you can dismiss and employee. However, if the conviction/s is spent, then the employee can take legal action under ‘unfair dismissal’.

As a general practice, it is highly recommended that you take out criminal record checks (also known as DBS checks) on all employees.

Sanctions Search

You should conduct a sanction search to determine if an applicant or employee has had any adverse media attention or affiliations with illegal entities. It will allow you to determine if an individual is prohibited from certain activities or industries; thus, protecting your company’s reputation and preventing adverse media attention.

In most cases, a sanction search is used to uncover any financial misdemeanours (e.g. trading under an insolvent company).

A sanctions search is usually conducted by government bodies, financial companies, or by UK employers who are hiring at senior/director level.

We discuss sanction searches in more detail here.

Poor Credit (e.g. bankruptcy, etc)

Whilst pre-employment credit checks are mandatory practice in the financial sector, you should implement a credit check if the role requires the handling of money and/or financial information (e.g. an accountant).

A typical pre-employment credit check will determine if your employee has any County Court Judgements (CCJs), bankruptcies, voluntary arrangements, decrees, or administration orders.

If you discover your applicant or employee has a bad credit history, then you should decide how much impact this may have on your business.

You cannot deny employment or dismiss an employee if they have a bad credit history, unless a good credit history is required for the role.

Driving Points and/or Convictions

If your employee drives on behalf of your organisation, then you must look out for driving convictions and points on their driving license.

If you fail to complete appropriate DVLA checks, then you will end up the hiring unsuitably qualified or dangerous drivers. And if they are involved in an accident, and it is proved they were driving as part of their job, your company can face large fines. Also, you will be charged under the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007.

We discuss DVLA checks in more detail here.

Social Media Checks

The use of social media checks as part of the employee screening process has increased in recent years. The aim of this check to organisations is to reduce the risk or brand and reputational damage that may be caused by an employee.

One aspect to note about social media checks is the grey area when it comes to privacy and data protection. Whilst social media appears to in the public domain, a lot of social media profiles are private or limited to the public. You can only conduct social media checks on profiles in the public domain, even if you have access to their private profile (e.g., through a mutual connection).

Do note, social media checks should only be used to look out for bullying, racism, sexism, defamation, and other negative behaviours. If you discover an employee is engaging in negative behaviour on social media, you must assess any potential risks to your organisation before speaking to the employee.

Employee Screening Software

The main takeaway from this article is that a basic employee screening/background check process will only help you to an extent. But to fully protect your organisation, you should have a process that ensures staff are qualified, educated, and experienced as per the information provided in their application.

Of course, ensuring the legitimacy of the information provided can put a lot on your plate. In addition, there are compliance considerations and efficiency factors to consider.

With this in mind, we developed Employment Check Pro.

Pro was developed to provide your organisation with a robust, efficient, and compliant employee screening platform. What’s more, the software is tailored to your industry, requirements, and covers all background checks.

To learn more about Employment Check Pro, visit /pro/ or fill in the form below to book a demo:

    Join Our Community for Exclusive Updates!

    Stay informed about the latest industry trends, news, and special offers. Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive content and promotions. Be the first to know—sign up now!

    This will close in 0 seconds